fbpx

Table of Contents

Does Jones v Dunkel Apply in Criminal Cases in NSW?

court room

The legal landscape is shaped by landmark cases that establish fundamental principles and guide the application of law in various jurisdictions. Jones v Dunkel is one such case that holds significance in the context of evidence and inferences in court proceedings.

What Is Jones v Dunkel Rule?

Jones v Dunkel is an Australian High Court case that was decided in 1959. The case concerned a plaintiff’s failure to call a witness who could have provided essential evidence to support their claim.

 

The court ruled that when a party fails to call a witness who could reasonably be expected to support their case, an adverse inference can be drawn against that party. This means that if the witness’s testimony would likely have strengthened the party’s case, the court may infer that the witness’s testimony would have been unfavourable to that party as they were not called to give evidence.

 

The Jones v Dunkel rule is grounded in the principle that parties to legal proceedings are under an obligation to adduce all relevant evidence available to them. Failure to do so may lead the court to draw an adverse inference that the evidence would have been unfavourable to that party and that the evidence would not have assisted that party. This can impact the ultimate outcome of the case as a inference favourable to the other party can be drawn.

The Jones v Dunkel 1959, rule is usually applied in civil cases to address situations where a party fails to present crucial evidence or witnesses. For example, if a plaintiff fails to call a witness who was present during an accident and could have provided key details about the incident, the court may infer that the witness’s testimony would not have supported the plaintiff’s version of events. This occurs where the plaintiff there is unexplained failure.

 

In civil cases, the rule serves as a means to level the playing field and ensure that parties do not withhold evidence that could potentially undermine their claims. It encourages parties to act in good faith and present all relevant evidence available to them, promoting a fair and just resolution of disputes.

Application of Jones v Dunkel in Criminal Cases in NSW

The application of Jones v Dunkel in criminal cases in NSW is a nuanced topic and has been the subject of debate among legal scholars and practitioners. However, the general consensus is that the Jones v Dunkel rule is not directly applicable in criminal cases in NSW.

 

Unlike civil cases, where the burden of proof rests on the balance of probabilities, criminal cases involve the higher standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In criminal cases, the prosecution bears the burden of proving the guilt of the accused. The accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty, and they are not obliged to adduce any evidence in their defence.

 

The right to silence is a fundamental principle in criminal law. The accused has the right to remain silent during the trial, and their silence cannot be used against them. This principle aligns with the idea that the prosecution must prove the accused’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, regardless of whether the accused presents evidence or calls witnesses.

Need a Traffic Lawyer in Sydney?

Send An Online Enquiry

“Thank you Lyons Law Group on providing me an exceptional service delivered with care, compassion and a high level of professionalism. The outcome was more than what I had expected. A true reflection of your legal expertise and experience. Thank you Mohammad and team.”
Layalle Itaoui

Exceptions to the Rule of Jones v Dunkel

However, there can be exceptional circumstances in criminal cases where an adverse inference may arise due to the accused’s actions. For instance:

 

Failure to Answer Questions

 

If the accused provides inconsistent or evasive answers during police questioning or fails to account for their whereabouts at the time of the alleged crime, the court may draw an adverse inference against them. This inference does not stem from the Jones v Dunkel rule but from the conduct of the accused during the investigation.

 

Alibi Witnesses

 

In some situations, the defence may inform the prosecution about potential alibi witnesses (witnesses who can testify that the accused was elsewhere at the time of the alleged crime). If the defence fails to call these witnesses during the trial, the court may draw an adverse inference, but this is based on the specific circumstances of the case and not the Jones v Dunkel rule.

 

Accordingly, the Jones v Dunkel rule does not directly apply in criminal cases in NSW due to the fundamental differences in the burden of proof and the right to silence. Criminal defendants are not under any obligation to present evidence or witnesses in their defence, and their silence cannot be used against them.

 

However, there are exceptions where the conduct of the accused during the investigation or trial may result in an adverse inference being drawn against them. These exceptions are specific to individual cases and should not be confused with the application of the Jones v Dunkel rule in civil cases.

 

If you are going to a defended hearing in a criminal matter, it is essential to seek legal advice from our traffic lawyers in Sydney. Our free consultation lawyers will assist you in discussing your case.

Our Recent Articles

What Our Clients Say About Us

Mansoor RamzanMansoor Ramzan
16:17 15 Apr 24
Lyons Law Mohammed khan,hijran, and the team have done the fantastic work.The team is really knowledgeable, professional, and capable of doing the law work.I highly recommend Lyons lawyer and especially Mr. Khan.
Lyons lawyers, principal solicitor khan, Hijran and the staff have been absolutely fantastic, friendly and efficient in handling my DV matters.The team is thoroughly professional, highly knowledgeable and I couldn’t recommend them enough. If you are in need of a law firm that genuinely cares, I highly recommend Lyons lawyers.
Maan TVMaan TV
20:34 31 Jan 24
Best lawyer ,very kind and corporative staff. 100% satisfactory results.
Liv MLiv M
03:52 16 Jan 24
Md SajibMd Sajib
09:47 10 Jan 24
Nuralam MiaNuralam Mia
03:17 10 Jan 24
Md RiponMd Ripon
04:31 07 Jan 24
Nur MohammadNur Mohammad
11:02 05 Jan 24
Mshafiq786 ShafiqMshafiq786 Shafiq
10:26 26 Dec 23
SohagSohag
08:29 26 Dec 23
King AhmedKing Ahmed
04:00 26 Dec 23
Hijran has been the best and nicest lawyer there is
Muhammad Aslam sajidMuhammad Aslam sajid
10:41 20 Dec 23
Hani MakkiHani Makki
01:56 20 Dec 23
I engaged Hijran from Lyons Law. She was fantastic. She studied my case closely, even after understanding my record was well below average She decided to assist me. She conducted herself well, was always prompt, professional and helpful. She explained my best and worst outcome. She worked diligently and got me the best outcome NO CONVICTION!!! I would like to extend my gratitude to Hijran. Thank you so much.
Anowar SorkarAnowar Sorkar
01:25 20 Dec 23
Sana MollahSana Mollah
02:04 17 Dec 23
Aiyub Ahamed JabinAiyub Ahamed Jabin
13:54 15 Dec 23
MdAbul HossainMdAbul Hossain
02:23 15 Dec 23
Younus RahamanYounus Rahaman
22:49 12 Dec 23
SHAHIN HossainSHAHIN Hossain
11:49 08 Dec 23
Rubel HossenRubel Hossen
01:29 08 Dec 23
Aman UllahAman Ullah
03:15 06 Dec 23
Dennis BernalDennis Bernal
08:18 05 Dec 23
Lyons Law Group provides such a holistic experience. Such exceptional services and could not recommend, Mohammad, Hijran and the team enough. Sound communication and always going above and beyond. The team represented a family member of mine that achieved the best outcome because of the quality of work and time invested into the matter. From my family, to the dream team at Lyons Law Group, thank you!
Rezaul karim RanaRezaul karim Rana
01:47 03 Dec 23
MD. Ramim HassanMD. Ramim Hassan
09:27 30 Nov 23
hridoy hasan pipluhridoy hasan piplu
04:36 29 Nov 23
PM. ParvejPM. Parvej
04:49 27 Nov 23
ShantoShanto
03:55 26 Nov 23
Md Ismaile hossenMd Ismaile hossen
10:46 25 Nov 23
MD SohelMD Sohel
10:33 25 Nov 23
Sheikh SajibSheikh Sajib
10:12 23 Nov 23
Your MotherYour Mother
07:13 20 Nov 23
Legends!!
SophieSophie
02:22 23 Oct 23
"Absolutely fantastic lawyer! Enis Erdem is a true professional who handles cases with skill, dedication, and genuine concern for their clients. He kept me informed throughout the entire process, making sure I understood every step. Enis Erdem is not only knowledgeable but also empathetic, which made a stressful legal situation much more manageable. I can't thank him enough for their outstanding work!"Highly recommended
Bahaddin DibBahaddin Dib
04:59 10 Oct 23
I had Mr khan who is the principal solicitor represent me today, Mr khan fought for me all the way and got me the best result possible. I would highly recommend him for all your law matters and can confidently say that he strives his best for his clients.
Mash HasanMash Hasan
00:38 21 Sep 23
Thank you so much. Great team of criminal defence lawyers.
Joanna StobinskiJoanna Stobinski
02:18 03 Sep 23
I found Lyons Law to be pro-active and easy to work with when dealing with the recent court case of my son.
Joseph BorgJoseph Borg
22:50 02 Aug 23
Mohammad and the team at the Lyons Law Group are a great to work with, they are polite and go above and beyond to help. We are very happy with the assistance they provided our family. I'd highly recommend the team at Lyons Law Group!
Shofiul AzamShofiul Azam
03:32 19 Jul 23
Mr Khan has extensive knowledge of the law and I am very much delighted about his service.
Julie NJulie N
07:12 11 Jul 23
Mohamad and Hijran are professional and straight to the point team. Highly recommended.
samdani gsamdani g
05:35 22 Jun 23
Very friendly and hard working
Mohammad and his time are the greatest criminal lawyers I have dealt with, they are extremely professional and can assist with any cases, big or small.
DR BernoussiDR Bernoussi
04:16 07 Mar 23
Mr Khan was so polite and helpful in directing me to the best possible outcome for my situation. The amount of support and knowledge they offered me was next to none. I didn’t feel like I was being mislead or looked at like a piggy bank. Mr khan and his team have your best interest into getting the best outcome. Pleasure guys kind regards Dr bernoussi
Natasha SusmanNatasha Susman
09:20 26 Jan 23
Lyons Law Group is honestly outstanding ! Hijran especially, not only is she so professional but she does her best and always is there to answer all questions with such understanding. Hijran honestly goes above and beyond and I'll forever be grateful. I highly recommend Lyons Group.
steve .H.steve .H.
16:59 26 Dec 22
A big thank you to Lyons law group, very professional. Mohammad was exceptionally well and handled my case amazing as well as Hijran!!! They really care about your case, I highly recommend this company!
Norris “Chuck” LuNorris “Chuck” Lu
04:15 30 Nov 22
I cannot express my gratitude to the Lyons law team with a big special mention to Mohammad. Having spent the last few years enduring and coping with the most difficult and stressful situation of me and my family's life.I have been using Mohammad and the team at Lyons Law from day one. They guided us through each difficult process in the most professional manner with full transparency, care and compassion.Through each difficult process up to the very last moment they only delivered results that exceeded every and anything we could have expected. Every outcome was exactly as planned and in turn got amazing results.So once again I cannot recommend Mohammad and the team at Lyons law enough. So like I and my Family did, have confidence that Lyons law will always strive for and deliver the best possible outcome.
Omar MOmar M
01:31 16 Nov 22
A BIG thank you to Lyons Law Group with helping me achieve the best outcome for my case. From day one they were very professional, straight to the point and very easy to communicate with, keeping me updated and informed with everything I needed to know. Honestly, exceptional service and support.Thank you once again to Mohammad & Team.
Edward HindsEdward Hinds
05:59 07 Nov 22
Lyons Law Group is amazing. They are very professional, sympathetic, and helpful. I was kept informed during every step. The level of support was second to none. Mohammad went above and beyond and updated me regularly. Hijram too was amazing. Her calls and court representation made me feel at ease. This was a great experience. I cannot recommend Lyons Law Group enough. My gratitude extends to all involved in the handling of my case.
js_loader

Author

  • Lyons Law Group | Criminal Defence Lawyers

    Lyons Law Group is a boutique firm of expert criminal solicitors and barristers. Lyons Law Group is dedicated to strong advocacy when representing its clients with an approach that is tailored to every client’s specific needs.